← Back to compare hub

APort vs Keycard

Both address runtime authorization. Compare the policy contract and enforcement boundary your workflow needs.

Sources reviewed . Vendor descriptions, not a hands-on comparative test.

Keycard combines delegated credential access with runtime policy enforcement. Its documentation describes checks before credential issuance and delivery, gateway checks on tool calls, and an audit log. APort evaluates passport capabilities, configured business-action limits and action context through supported integrations.

Consider a support agent that reads a customer record and requests a refund. Access to the service and authority for the particular operation are related requirements. Compare which component establishes customer entitlement, constrains the amount, owns the credential and prevents an unchecked call. APort's payment policies do not replace those application responsibilities.

Comparison pointOAP / APortKeycard
Authorization modelPassport-based authorization for payment, data, repository and tool actions; task completion requirements. The integration must enforce the decision.User, application and resource identity, Cedar policies and credential access; gateway checks on individual tool calls.
Enforcement and credentialsYour hook, repository check or service executor enforces the decision. Hosted verification alone does not remove other credential paths.CLI, MCP Gateway or server SDK supplies the enforcement point. The SDK can obtain upstream credentials in the server rather than the agent.
EvidenceHosted signed decisions where configured, plus a public payment benchmark. Execution outcomes and completeness require separate evidence.Documents an Audit Log for access decisions. Validate the fields, retention and evidence export needed by your reviewers.
Completion requirementsA configured task-completion policy evaluates submitted evidence requirements. Managed software delivery remains restricted preview; attestations are not independent proof of correctness.The referenced guide describes runtime access and credential delivery. Evaluate task-completion gates separately with your proposed workflow.

Use Keycard when

  • Evaluate credential delivery and delegated access tied to your existing identity provider.
  • Assess its gateway or server SDK when upstream credential ownership is central to the design.

Use OAP / APort when

  • Evaluate passport-defined business-action limits for payments, customer data or code.
  • Require inspectable policy decisions and test enforcement in an existing application.
  • Explore completion requirements alongside action authorization, with preview limits explicit.

What to evaluate with OAP / APort

Business actions as policy inputs

Inspect the configured refund, data-access and repository rules. Run the same allowed and denied workload through the integration you intend to deploy.

Separate permission from completion

A permitted tool call does not prove a task was delivered. Evaluate required evidence, reviewer identity and actual execution outcomes separately.

Sources

Read these sources alongside the table and use-case tradeoffs. The comparison is APort's interpretation; each source describes its own system.

Plan your workflow pilotProtect my GitHub repo